Blog / News

Controversial DNA Test

daily news

Queens judge is first in nation to approve controversial DNA test

By Thomas Zambito
DAILY NEWS STAFF WRITER

A Queens judge has become the first in the nation to approve a controversial DNA-tracking technique that can nail criminals with a speck of blood or the mere touch of a finger.

Wednesday’s precedent-setting decision by Supreme Court Justice Robert Hanophy came in the case of Hemant Megnath, a man prosecutors say slashed a young woman’s throat just before she was about to testify against him in a rape case.

Hanophy sided with Queens prosecutors who want to tell jurors about a trace of blood on a seat belt in victim Natasha Ramen’s car linked to Megnath through “touch DNA” testing.

The technique has been used overseas to win convictions in several high-profile criminal cases.
Such evidence also has been used in U.S. courts, and the city medical examiner has a lab devoted to it.

But Megnath’s lawyer Todd Greenberg challenged the tests – and Hanophy held a series of hearings in 2008.

“There is still a raging debate among scientists as to the reliability,” Greenberg said, “ the judge ruled against us.”

Now Greenberg will have to attack the science behind touch DNA before a jury as Megnath goes on trial next week in the 2007 slaying.

The test is largely the same as traditional DNA analysis, but allows scientists to scrutinize microscopic skin or blood cells. Critics say amplifying tiny samples distorts the results.

Posted in:

Related Posts

ada ag7

A & G at the Queens ADA Gala in Honor of Judge Holder

What a night! So honored to be part of the Queens ADA Association Summer Dinner celebrating Judicial Excellence — and the incredible career of the Honorable Judge Kenneth Holder on his retirement.

weatherspoon

$500K SLIP AND FALL ON ICE

Our client was at a storage facility when she tripped and fell on ice. The facility had shoveled from a storm the night before, but the theory of liability was that employees failed to properly salt. Throughout the case the offer was $25K, with Defense counsel pointing to the snowstorm the night before and all other issues that are commonly raised as a defense in snow and ice fall cases. However, on the eve of trial, Plaintiff’s Counsel Todd D. Greenberg made a Motion in Limine to admit post-accident repairs in the form of a picture of  salt applied to the ice after the accident by management. What was clearly apparent was that the salt had a blue hue to it, which was missing in the picture of the actual accident scene! It was clear that the Defendant failed to salt the shoveled walkway in a proper manner, giving rise to liability. The Plaintiff suffered a bilateral fractured ankle and the case settled for $500,000.00 the day before jury selection after the Motion was filed! For a slip and fall on ice, sidewalk or other defective condition, call Addabbo & Greenberg at 718-268-0400 or visit our website at www.queenslaw.com

Jury Verdict: ‘NOT GUILTY” of Manslaughter, Criminal Negligent Homicide

Kevin Gomez, 22, was acquitted of felony manslaughter in the fatal 2023 hit-and-run death of three-year-old Quintus Chen in Queens, New York, but a jury found him guilty of misdemeanor charges including reckless driving and operating an unregistered vehicle. Queens Daily Eagle Prosecutors argued Gomez’s tinted windows severely impaired his visibility, yet he struck the child and fled the scene, while his defense countered that Gomez was merging into traffic and did not see the child, calling the tragedy an accidental “pedestrian error.” Queens Daily Eagle Gomez faces sentencing on December 10 and could receive either probation or up to a year behind bars. Queens Daily Eagle Click the link to read the full article.